Critical anthropology has had a major influence on the discipline, shifting it away from concepts of bounded societies with evolutionary trajectories to complex analyses of interconnected economic, political, and social processes. This book brings together some of critical anthropology’s most influential writings, collecting classic articles and spirited rebuttals by major scholars such as Eric Wolf, Marshall Sahlins, Sidney Mintz, Andre Gunder Frank, and Michael Taussig. Editor Stephen Nugent positions these key debates, originally published in the journal Critique of Anthropology, with new introductions that detail the lasting influence of these articles on anthropology over four decades, showing how critical anthropology is relevant today more than ever. An ideal supplementary text, this book is a rich exploration of intellectual history that will continue to shape anthropology for decades to come.
Editor Stephen Nugent brings together some of critical anthropology’s most influential writings by major scholars, pairing key articles with lively rebuttals and new introductions that detail the continuing influence of these key debates on anthropology over four decades.
Stephen Nugent teaches anthropology at Goldsmiths, University of London, and is director of the Centre for Visual Anthropology. His long-term interest in Brazilian Amazonia is represented in his books, Big Mouth (1990), Amazonian Caboclo Society (1993) and Some Other Amazonians (2004). He is an editor of the journal Critique of Anthropology.
CONTENTS
Introduction
I. Marxism in the American anthropological tradition
1. On defining the Marxist tradition in anthropology: a response to the American Anthropologist, Stanley Diamond, Bob Scholte and Eric R. Wolf (1975)
2. The worst of architects is better than the best of bees: a debate between Eric Wolf and Maurice Godelier, As rendered by JlR