Malevolent Legalitiesdraws upon archival research conducted at the Scalia Papers at the Harvard Law School Historical and Special Collections to examine the influence of Justice Antonin Scalias judicial philosophy of textualist-originalism on the US Supreme Courts antidiscrimination jurisprudence. The book focuses on six US Supreme Court cases, organized into two parts. The main argument of the book, grounded in archival and legal materials, is that textualist-originalism makes it lawful for discrimination to be performed through the text, and explicitly seeks to prevent progress by enacting a regime of static law.
InShelby County v. Holder(2013), Justice Ginsburg remarked that discrimination today behaves like the Hydra, the many-headed serpent in Ancient Greek mythology which regenerates each time its head is severed. The analysis of archival and legal materials is therefore prefaced by the development of a unique methodology for studying discrimination calleddiscriminatology, understood as a framework for analyzing how discrimination persists through time, is performed through the text, and is a product of the manipulation of legal speech. In this way,Malevolent Legalitiesapproaches the study of textualist-originalism as itself a vehicle for discrimination performedmala fideor in bad faith.
Malevolent Legalities argues that Justice Antonin Scalia's textualist-originalism makes it lawful for discrimination to be performed through the text and seeks to prevent progress by enacting a regime of static law. The author utilizes archival and legal research to show how the specters of Scalia haunt our contemporary legal reality.
Kevin S. Jobeis assistant professor of philosophy at the University of Texas-Rio Grande Valley.
Kevin S. Jobe philosophically advances judicial skepticism to show how the US Supreme Courts use of textualism and originalism is performative discrimination. Jobes brilliant analyses