Believable Evidence [Hardcover]

The first comprehensive account of the nature of evidence, presenting innovative and influential arguments concerning the ontology of reasons.Believable Evidence argues that evidence consists of true beliefs. The first contemporary monograph entirely devoted to the ontology of evidence, it challenges a broad range of current views on reasons in an accessible way, making it a must-read for scholars and advanced students in metaethics and epistemology.Believable Evidence argues that evidence consists of true beliefs. The first contemporary monograph entirely devoted to the ontology of evidence, it challenges a broad range of current views on reasons in an accessible way, making it a must-read for scholars and advanced students in metaethics and epistemology.Believable Evidence argues that evidence consists of true beliefs. This claim opens up an entirely overlooked space on the ontology of evidence map, between purely factualist positions (such as those of Williamson and Dancy) and purely psychologist ones (such as that of Conee and Feldman). Veli Mitova provides a compelling three-level defence of this view in the first contemporary monograph entirely devoted to the ontology of evidence. First, once we see the evidence as a good reason, metaethical considerations show that the evidence must be psychological and veridical. Second, true belief in particular allows epistemologists to have everything they want from the concept of evidence. Finally, the view helps us locate the source of the normative authority of evidence. The book challenges a broad range of current views on the ontology of reasons and their normative authority, making it a must-read for scholars and advanced students in metaethics and epistemology.Part I. Solid Metaethical Foundations: 1. The standard story; 2. The beast of two burdens; 3. Extreme psychologism about reasons; 4. Truthy; Part II. Sound Epistemological Structure: 5. Truthy psychologism; 6. Truthy psychologism gives us everything we want; l*